Pemollow

THYB on Facebook

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Refuting Trinity For Dummies


Assalamualaikum. Hye.

This article is only filled with simple analogies and imagery. No need complex facts and statistics. Anyone can understand. Understand what? Understanding how trinity is a false concept. A big fallacy.

First, we all know that almost every church has its very own way to define trinity. But here is one. Let us take an example from a website that is very loud when it comes to calling for trinity.

Sani Musa Wukari asked WHAT IS TRINITY ?

According to the Qur'an, Trinity is God the Father, God the Son (Isa) and Isa's mother Maryam. 

But since I do not subscribe to the ignorance of Muhammad, here is my definition of TRINITY:

The Trinity refers to "the unity of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit as three persons." The word "Trinity," is formed from the words "tri-" and "unity," and describes "th
e state of being threefold." In other words, to believe in the Trinity means to believe that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are essentially one God, even while they retain their own set of differences.

Well, Here goes...
#1 According to the Qur'an, Trinity is God the Father, God the Son (Isa) and Isa's mother Maryam. 

First and foremost, the Quran never approves trinity or anything like that. What Quran does is to reject it. We can refer to Quran 5:116 and Quran 4:171. Let's see one by one.

Quran 5:116 


And [beware the Day] when Allah will say, "O Jesus, Son of Mary, did you say to the people, 'Take me and my mother as deities besides Allah ?'" He will say, "Exalted are You! It was not for me to say that to which I have no right. If I had said it, You would have known it. You know what is within myself, and I do not know what is within Yourself. Indeed, it is You who is Knower of the unseen.

Clearly stated about how Allah will ask Jesus one day, did he or did he not tell his people to take him (Jesus) and his mother (Mary) as Gods other from Allah? And Look at Jesus's answer. You can judge by yourself whether or not Quran accept trinity or rejects it.

Quran 4:171 


O People of the Scripture, do not commit excess in your religion or say about Allah except the truth. The Messiah, Jesus, the son of Mary, was but a messenger of Allah and His word which He directed to Mary and a soul [created at a command] from Him. So believe in Allah and His messengers. And do not say, "Three"; desist - it is better for you. Indeed, Allah is but one God. Exalted is He above having a son. To Him belongs whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. And sufficient is Allah as Disposer of affairs.

It also clearly tells about how Allah already mentioned to the People of the Book, not to say THREE when it comes to God. But then, you can guess how misleading they are today.


#2 But since I do not subscribe to the ignorance of Muhammad, here is my definition of TRINITY:
Well if you're unsubscribing Muhammad, you're subscribing the ignorance. Choose well.


#3 The Trinity refers to "the unity of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit as three persons."
This is really ridiculous. Come on. Tell me again how this sentence is actually make sense. The UNITY of the father, the son, and the holy spirit as THREE personS. So where is the unity? It is clearly stated THREE personS but then it is only one God?

Hye there! I have one ice-cream, one balloon, and one teddy bear. But I have them united as ONE MONKEY!!!

Is that make sense to you? Of course it will not. When the items are of different characteristics and criteria, they cannot be simply called as ONE SAME THING. Even if humans are different from each other, how come human can be same as spirit and worse, God?


#4 The word "Trinity," is formed from the words "tri-" and "unity," and describes "th
e state of being threefold."
Ok. Now things get even more ridiculous. Now God is 3 in 1 like a premix coffee? Maybe they want to simulate God like a cup of coffee. Made of coffee, sugar, and creme. But is one coffee drink. Well, if the coffee is changed to chocolate, it will then become chocolate drink. It it changes to mocha, then it will become mocha drink.

See the relationships. What makes a coffee drink a coffee drink is the coffee. Not the sugar, not the creme. So does God. What makes a God is a God. Not human, not spirit. Because in the end, you will never call sugar as coffee even though it is part of the coffee drink. As sugar is still sugar. It taste sweet and not bitter.

So there is no such a thing like a God + a human + a spirit = God. Please no blasphemy. God is one and has no associates. Ever.


#5 In other words, to believe in the Trinity means to believe that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are essentially one God, even while they retain their own set of differences.
With this, we shall go the in-depth explanation why trinity concept is flawed. First, look at how trinity is defined as believing the father, son, and holy spirit as one God while retaining their characteristics.

We can accept an ostrich, a penguin, a kiwi, and an eagle as Birds. It is so stupid to call them ONE bird but let say they are indeed one bird. What keeps them together is their SIMILAR characteristics. Each of them has feathers. Each of them has a beak. Each of them has talons. So they are indeed, ONE bird.

Although the truth is clear they are of different species so they are THREE birdS.

But now let us take a look at Yahweh, Jesus, and Holy Spirit. Yahweh is the so called God is a God. Maybe. But Jesus is a man. He was born out of a woman's womb. He eats and sleeps and grow like any other humans. The only thing different is that he was born without a father, without conception. And the holy spirit, well, he is a spirit.

Even in Bible is said that God is a spirit. "A" spirit if you don't notice. So okay let us say holy spirit and yahweh are spirits so they are of the same characteristics. But still, Jesus is a man. You can't say otherwise. 

LUKE 24:39 {24:39} Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself: handle me, and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have. 

Jesus had clearly differentiated himself from God.What more do we need?

God is one. Not one of three or three of one or threefold or whatsoever. ONE is ONE. Simplest way to understand God. If we put God as the highest power, then he will be at the highest alone. If we ever say God is three or the One God is of three aspects, each of them has their own specific characters, then where is the ONENESS of God?

If God is the Father, the Son, adn the Holy Spirit, then for whatever things happening on this earth, from who's decision is that? The Father? The Son? Or the Spirit?

Like I said. Putting three distinct things as one thing is absurd. How is that even possible? They share body? Or bodies? Wait! God needs a body? That's blasphemy!

And if by saying God is omnipotent, the he can become a man. That's a rubbish argument. Will you agree if I say God is omnipotent so he ca be anything. He can be a garbage fly. He can be a handicapped boy. He can be a slut.

Isn't that what you mean?

To compare God becoming a man is like to say a king becoming a slave. Two different ranking and status. Two different functions. Two different roles. Two distinct characters. Therefore those contradicting things can't be together in one being. Especially in this "a man and a God" case.

Even by mathematical reasoning, trinity is false. We all know that if A = B, and B = C, then A = C. But different scenario occurs with trinity.

Yahweh = God. Jesus = God. Holy Spirit = God. But then Yahweh is not = Jesus. Jesus is not = Holy Spirit. And Holy Spirit is not = Yahweh. See the ridiculousness?

Therefore God needs to be ONE. Like how Quran 112 beautifully describe it.



There are no concept that can explain trinity. Because nothing can explain the false thing. Well then, drop me some comments of you want to add something or as questions. Till next time.

Thanks for reading. Bye ;)

No comments: